Trailer
Review
In 'Moana,' director Thomas Kail takes the beloved animated story and reimagines it as a live-action spectacle, anchored by a performance from newcomer Catherine Lagaʻaia that feels like a genuine discovery. She brings a fierce, grounded determination to Moana, making the character's journey from cautious daughter to bold wayfinder deeply personal. The film opens with a striking sequence on Motunui, where the lush greens and vibrant blues of the island are captured with a naturalistic warmth that immediately pulls you in. Dwayne Johnson as Maui is a perfect fit, his charisma and comic timing intact, though the demigod's tattoos are rendered with practical effects that sometimes feel more distracting than charming. The pacing is brisk, with the first act setting up Moana's internal conflict—her love for her people versus her pull to the ocean—with efficient storytelling. The musical score, blending traditional Pacific Islander rhythms with sweeping orchestral pieces, is the film's heartbeat, especially during the song 'How Far I'll Go,' which Lagaʻaia delivers with raw, aching sincerity. The cinematography by Dion Beebe is a standout, using sweeping dolly shots and intimate close-ups to capture the scale of the ocean and the vulnerability of the characters. However, the film struggles with tonal consistency; scenes of genuine danger, like the encounter with the volcanic monster Te Kā, clash with lighthearted, almost slapstick moments involving Maui's shapeshifting. The script also loses some of the original's thematic depth, simplifying Moana's connection to her ancestors into a more straightforward hero's call. Despite these stumbles, the film's heart remains intact, and Lagaʻaia's performance alone makes it a worthwhile voyage.
Pros
- ✓Catherine Lagaʻaia's breakout performance: she embodies Moana with a quiet strength and emotional range that elevates every scene, especially her solo moments on the beach.
- ✓The musical score and song integration: the new arrangements of classic songs and the original score blend seamlessly, using live instruments to create a richer, more organic soundscape.
- ✓Cinematography that captures the vastness of the Pacific: Dion Beebe uses natural light and sweeping camera movements to make the ocean feel like a living, breathing character.
- ✓The practical and CGI blend for Maui's fish hook: the visual effects team creates a tangible, weighty object that feels like an ancient artifact, grounding the fantasy elements.
Cons
- ✗Tonal whiplash between dramatic and comedic scenes: the film shifts abruptly from life-or-death stakes to comedic banter, undercutting the emotional tension.
- ✗Underdeveloped supporting characters: Moana's parents and the villagers are given little screen time, making the stakes of restoring prosperity feel abstract rather than personal.
- ✗A few overlong action sequences: the chase with the Kakamora pirates drags on, relying on repetitive slapstick that feels out of place with the film's more contemplative moments.
This live-action 'Moana' is a film that reaches for the stars but sometimes stumbles on the reef. While it lacks the seamless flow of its animated predecessor, it compensates with a lead performance that is nothing short of revelatory. Catherine Lagaʻaia's Moana is a protagonist you will root for, and the film's visual splendor—from the shimmering ocean to the fiery peaks of Te Fiti—is a feast for the eyes. The music remains unforgettable, and the central message of self-discovery and cultural pride is handled with respect. However, the uneven tone and underdeveloped side characters prevent it from achieving greatness. It is not a flawless remake, but it is an earnest and often beautiful one. If you can accept its flaws, you will find a story that still has the power to inspire. For families and fans of the original, this is a solid, heartfelt adventure that honors its source material while carving its own path.
🎯 Who Should Watch
Families with children aged 8 and up, fans of the original animated film, and anyone who enjoys heartfelt adventure stories with strong female leads and Pacific Islander cultural representation.
⭐ Standout Elements
The performances of Catherine Lagaʻaia and Dwayne Johnson, the breathtaking cinematography of the ocean and island landscapes, and the emotionally resonant musical sequences that blend tradition with cinematic grandeur.
🎬 Overall Impact
A must-watch film that delivers on both entertainment and emotional depth.
📽️ This film represents solid filmmaking that deserves your attention.
About the Reviewer
Elena Rostova covers global releases, animation, and film festival entries from around the world.















